VonLehman is now part of Dean Dorton. Click here to learn more about the merger.

How to Land Major Donors

11/09/2022 Dalena McGrew

Nonprofits typically don’t pass on donations from its donor base no matter what the size. Modest donations, after all, add up. But those big donations and regular large donors can make a world of difference to an organization’s financial security.

Unfortunately, major donors don’t usually knock on a charity’s door and hand over millions of dollars. You have to work to find them and then earn their trust and confidence. Here are seven practical suggestions:

  1. Push your Annual Appeal. Your annual appeal is a great way to accumulate undesignated money. Typically, this funding is used to pay day-to-day operational expenses and to support your overall mission — and whatever is left over can be used for new initiatives, program expansion and other projects. Annual appeals usually have a secondary purpose: They enable you to strengthen bonds with your nonprofit’s supporters. To keep your annual appeal robust and even grow it, spend time evaluating current donors to determine whether they’ve reached their full giving-level potential. Focus on those who’ve made large contributions in the past but might not have done so in recent years or on mid-level donors who may be prepared to take the next step but need a nudge.
  2. Research prospects. A donor’s record of contributing to similar or complementary nonprofits can indicate a willingness to at least listen to your pitch. As the names of potential donors cross your radar, gather information about their community involvement and philanthropic interests. Then tailor your message to your audience and who will deliver that message. For example, if a prospect has been an advocate for other children related special needs programs, they may be interested in being involved and donating to another assistance program related to children.
  3. Work special events. If you hold special events such as an annual gala, make sure you meet supporters’ guests, particularly guests of major donors. These guests may already be interested in your cause and are more likely to donate if a friend or business associate is a big supporter of your organization. If your event sponsors live and silent auctions, pay attention to the high bidders and follow up with them either at the event or the following week. This is a great opportunity to get your board members involved and interacting with gala attendees. You could even assign board members and key staff specific donors to seek out during the event.
  4. Take an interest in politics. The type of people who make large contributions to political campaigns also often generously support charities. Making political gifts indicates someone has the resources to give and the desire to invest personally in a cause. Unless your prospects donate exclusively to political action committees, their political donation records generally should be public.
  5. Locate the wealth. One way to identify wealthy individuals in your community is to research public property records. Targeting real estate owners may at first seem like a strange suggestion, but research has shown a correlation between expensive property ownership and charitable giving. You can obtain property owner information from county tax assessors and current property values from sites such as Zillow and Trulia.
  6. Network with for-profit companies. Companies can provide a large pool of potential donors if you can establish strong connections with them. For example, you might partner with a local business for an employee volunteer day or snag a large national company sponsorship for an event. Working closely with the owners and executives of these companies gives you opportunities to sell them on your cause and mission. That way, when these individuals make charitable gifts, your organization will already be on their short list. The corporate world can provide you with excellent prospective board members.
  7. Make your database work for you. It’s critical to keep your donor database tidy and up to date with all donations. Regularly review it and eliminate deceased or inactive individuals, verify and update information such as addresses and phone numbers, and consolidate duplicate entries. If you don’t already have procedures for entering data into your donor database, document them now and make sure all staffers follow them. Also, although you don’t need expensive technology, your database should be able to integrate with other software, provide automated communications, and function on a mobile-friendly basis.

If your staffers aren’t proficient with your database, arrange for software training so they’ll be able to maximize its potential.

These are just a sample of ways you can find major donors and increase overall donations. For any questions related to nonprofit donors and donations, contact Dalena McGrew at dmcgrew@vlcpa.com or 800.887.0437.

Have a Question? Contact Us

Contact Us